Al-Qadir Trust Case Hearings Spark Heated Clashes Over Counsel, Detainee Health, and Transparency
Politics

Al-Qadir Trust Case Hearings Spark Heated Clashes Over Counsel, Detainee Health, and Transparency

AI Quick Read
  • Justice Dogar barred Barrister Salman Safdar from speaking at the start of the Islamabad High Court hearing and called on Khosa to argue.
  • Defense counsel sought medical relief and a hospital transfer or bail for Bushra Bibi over an eye surgery requiring strict hygiene to protect her vision.
  • The court urged immediate arguments on the main appeals while offering only to have jail authorities assign a doctor to check on the matter.
  • Salman Safdar stated that a recent letter reflected statements dictated by Imran Khan regarding severe blood pressure spikes, heart health risks, and survival in custody.
  • Counsel sought live streaming of the Al-Qadir Trust proceedings and issued a contempt notice over non implementation of August medical directives.

Proceedings at the Islamabad High Court in the Al-Qadir Trust case on November 18, 2026 brought sharp disagreements over legal representation, detainee medical care, and courtroom transparency into full view. Following an earlier meeting between Imran Khan, Bushra Bibi, Barrister Salman Safdar, and Khosa, expectations had formed that Salman Safdar would lead the arguments on behalf of the accused. Both Salman Safdar and Khosa had publicly aligned with that understanding after the previous meeting, yet the bench's approach during the hearing quickly altered the dynamic.

At the outset of the session, Justice Dogar instructed Salman Safdar not to address the court. Salman Safdar attempted to explain that he and his team had been entrusted with arguing the matter, but the bench ordered him not to speak and directed Khosa to present arguments instead. When Khosa addressed the court, he raised urgent health concerns regarding Bushra Bibi, specifically an eye condition requiring surgery. Counsel argued that performing or managing such a procedure inside prison raises serious hygiene concerns, warning that infection or complications could jeopardize her remaining vision and leave her completely blind. Legal representatives sought either shifting her to a hospital for treatment or granting temporary bail for the duration of her medical care.

The bench responded by assuring counsel that Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi were in safe hands and pressed the defense to proceed immediately with arguments on the core appeals. On Bushra Bibi's medical request, the court indicated it would ask prison authorities to assign a doctor to examine her condition, stopping short of ordering hospital transfer or bail while continuing to push for arguments on the main appeals. Observers and legal commentators noted that pushing forward with substantive appeal arguments before resolving medical and procedural requests risks accelerating final rulings and subsequent appellate review at the constitutional court level.

Outside the courtroom, legal developments drew further attention. Salman Safdar provided additional context regarding a letter attributed to Imran Khan, stating that it followed a three hour and ten minute meeting, including seventy minutes focused on health concerns, and reflected statements dictated directly by Imran Khan. According to Salman Safdar, Imran Khan expressed alarm over elevated blood pressure readings reaching around 192 to 193, reported prior impact to part of his heart, warned of risks such as cerebral hemorrhage or cardiac arrest, and stressed that surviving in custody is essential to defending himself across pending cases. Salman Safdar also reiterated instructions for his legal team to pursue the Al-Qadir Trust matter both in court and in the public sphere, while requesting judicial approval for live streaming of the proceedings so the public can observe arguments, defense positions, and judicial conduct directly.

Separately, attorney Khalid Yousaf Chaudhry issued a notice to the Adiala Jail superintendent over non implementation of prior Supreme Court directives from August regarding medical access, warning of contempt proceedings if compliance is not ensured. Debate also surfaced online over minor typographical errors and spelling issues in the circulated letter, with commentary urging audiences to distinguish between clerical or transcription flaws and the substantive health and legal issues raised on behalf of detainees in custody. At the same time, notable attendance by PTI lawyers, Imran Khan's sisters, and Allama Raja Nasir Abbas at the court drew attention as legal teams navigated both courtroom pressure and public messaging.